गुरुवार, 25 जनवरी 2024

Bobby at 50 : A Tribute


Bobby at 50: A Tribute 
Raj Sahab; thank you for liberating us) 

‘Bobby’ a film on Teenage love story released in 1973 liberated the Middle class India ; the bulk of the film goers. It freed us from the clutches of our parental controls as the college crowd clapped, wept and cried watching Rishi Kapoor and Dimple, meeting, shying, loving, separating, fighting, cajoling, contesting, escaping, eloping, dancing, defying as their story unfolded on the screen. It reflected the sub - conscious desire of us all, our parents, grand parents, teachers and the masses. Raj Kapoor gave us a film which we had not even seen among the Hollywood cinema to which we were exposed.  'Summer of 42' did explore briefly this teenage desire to be together and the protagonist in it also did get liberated by the young widow whose husband had died in the ongoing world War. But it was Bobby which was near us and brought the colors and music for us on screen. The film lifted the Taboo . The commercial success of the film transformed the theme and story. A simple teenage love story written by the Marxist film maker and writer Khwaja Ahmad Abbas who had earlier written 'Awaara', 'Shree 420', 'Mera Naam Joker' for Raj Kapoor. It was a love story of a Boy of rich parents who do not have time for him and on account of his naughtiness is banished to boarding school . On his return to Home there is a grand party thrown by his parents in which his Nanny arrives uninvited to give him a cake. She is accompanied by her granddaughter ‘Bobby’ played by Dimple Kapadia. On seeing her Raj played by Rishi Kapoor falls in love with her, though they do not meet but he sings a song in the party" Main Shayar to nahin , magar ai haseen jab se dekha maine tumko ; mujhko shayri aagayi... ". Raj wants to meet her and visits his Nanny. They meet, fall in love, but the rich and poor conflict arises which after heart aches and adventures are overcome. They finally live together happily. Prior to Bobby there were many love stories about students. But the role of the students was played by elders and aged actors -Rajendra Kumar, Sunil Dutt, Manoj Kumar, Pradeep Kumar etc. With 'Bobby' it was perhaps the first time when the age of lead actors was realistic ( though Rishi was 21 at the time of release but he looked a teenager), Dimple was 16. They looked a convincing 'Teenage couple' and acted and sang' Teenage ' - " Hum tum ik kamre main band hon aur chabi kho jaye ". The magic which mesmerized us all was the presentation of the film. It was a love story in which new actors were introduced. It was perhaps the first time when a young love story had 'young lead actors'. Rishi had played a Chubby boy in ' Mera Naam joker' who falls in love with his teacher , but all that was forgotten when he arrived in slim and trim shape and was different and new and most viewers considered him to be a newcomer. Raj made this movie as a ‘bench mark’. Though it is learnt that he was not much hopeful of it's success. He had planned a big dacoit movie starring Dharmendra and Mumtaz titled ' Daud' based on the story of the famous Gujrati writer Abid Surti;but that was not to be. 

He expected ' Bobby' to be a moderate success film as the actors were new and perhaps it was sort of an experiment. Little did this creator knew that he will launch a new era of young love stories, a new norm a new genre in Hindi film cinema. No matter how skeptical and unsure he was of his film's success he controlled each aspect and department with astuteness for which he was known. His famous music director duo of Shankar Jaikishan had delivered their best music before Jaikishan died suddenly. Known not to many Raj Kapoor himself was a gifted musician and music was the core of his cinema. Shankar Jaikishan gave music to most of his films but it was distinctly Raj Kapoor music with most songs written by his favourite Shailendra. He made music sitting on his harmonium in his famous RK cottage with his team consisting of Shankar- Jaikishan, Shailendra, Hasrat Jaipuri, Mukesh and Lata. They made a formidable group which presented great music from Barsaat to Awaara to Shri 420 to Jis desh main Ganga behti hai to Sangam to Mera Naam Joker. In his films the music matched with the film step to step. Music was the soul of his cinema. This was in Bobby too but the voice, the sound the 'sur' of Bobby was different from his films prior and thereafter. ' Bobby' gave s new ‘sound’ a new ‘meter’ matching with the teenage love story . Music was by Laxmikant Pyerelal but after this the duo never gave a similar music in any of their films, the reason was that there was no Raj Kapoor. A new male voice in Shailendra Singh was discover ed. 'Main Shayar to Nahin..... ' Anand Bakshi wrote 5 out of 8 Songs but such new poetry, such newness and novelty was never witnessed there after, though he continued to be hugely successful and prolific. The reason again was Raj Kapoor and his creativity, his control and mediation and mastery. Two songs - ' na maangu sona chandi, na maangu bangla gaadi ye mere kis kaam ke.... ' and ' jhooth bole kawwa kate kale kawwe se dariyo main maike chali jaungi tum dekhte rahiyo' were written by Vithal bhai patel. Another sufi song ' besak mandir masjid to do Bulle shah ye kehta, par pyar bada dil kabhi na todo is mein dilbar reinda..... ' was sung by Chanchal and is credited to Raj Kavi Tulsi. In addition to Shailendra Singh folk singer Chanchal found success and did sing in films there after. The song sung by Chanchal and his words of ' separation and longing' set in Kashmir opened a new style and situation and used thereafter in films such as ' Hero' by Subhash Ghai where the folk singer Reshma sings on the beach ' chaar dina da mela lambi judai'. The two typical Goan/Koli songs ' na mangu... :' and ' jhoot bole' were extremely popular and added value to the film. Altogether along with the young couple the songs too were a great attraction. 

 The songs moved the story . The first song is sung by Rishi Kapoor in the party thrown by his father on his arrival from the boarding school . A ‘Famme –Fatale’ – Aruna Irani a friend of his mother and an easy going person dances to the song “ Mai shayar to nahin magar ae hasin tujhko dekhe jabse maine tabse shayri aagayi” the image of Dimple appears on the screen as she had left the scene with her grandmother in between , but Rishi had chanced upon her and was imagining her as he sang. The second song shows their love developing and acceptance of each other in various situations displaying the coyness and beauty of Dimple ( Bobby) . She is shown playing badminton ,swimming in a swimming suit, and then Rishi showering flowers on her as she is lazily lying in the garden . All the ingredients of a love blooming are presented through this song-“ Muzhe kuch keha hai…muzhe bhi kuch keha hai …pehle tum …pehle tum” . There occurs a misunderstanding between the two when Dimple is taken to a party by Raj and where he meets Aruna Irani. Bobby thinks that Raj was cheating on her and she goes away to Kashmir as part of the college trip . Raj; like a true lover follows her atop a bus and finds her camp and location. He tries to enter her camp but is beaten badly by the guards who think him to be a miscreant. Then the famous ‘haunting’ song of Chanchal is played on screen . Chanchal himself is on screen by the bonfire made by the village peoople/workers and sings this song on Daphli “ beshak mandir masjid todo Bullehshah ye kehta , par pyar bada dil kabhi na todo is men dilbar rehta, jis paddle main tule mohabat usmen chandi nahin todna dholna main nahin bolna ….” ( it says that we may break Masjid or Mandir but never break the heart where your lover resides……..never barter love for silver) . This music this style , these words were something new apart from Shailendra Singh this was the new voice on screen; now I can compare that like Kailesh Kher became famous at that time it was ‘Chanchal’. While the song is being played on screen Dimple in a black attire suitable to the Kashmir weather comes out of her tent , eyes red and swollen and Rishi stands firm at a distance despite the beating received. Their love had crossed yet another hurdle we in audience could gauge. The song and the words make the two lovers long for each other and differences and complaints seem to be forgotten . Bobby is yet to reconcile and whilst on a horse is unable to control it, probably she does it on purpose. Raj is behind and follows her , she is thrown away by the horse and is on the grass when Raj arrives , they yet again express their love for each other and embrace . Raj takes away Dimple from her friends and in the scenic surrounding of Kashmir they sing that naughty and yet highly romantic song , a unique song – “ hum tm ek kamre main band hon aur chabi kho jaye …….”( we two are closed in a room and the key is lost! ) imagining various silly and simple situations of danger and surprise and expecting a reply from the other.( hum tum yunhi jungle se guzren aur sher aajaye? ) – Sher se main kahun wo tumhen chod de muzhe kha jaye…..” Raj somehow convinces his parents to meet Bobby and her Parents- Father and Grand mother. Mr Jack Briganja is a ‘hands on’ fisherman who does good business , loud, robust, proud, large hearted who drinks rum; bottle tucked in his lungi. Raj is happy and goes to the residence of Bobby to announce the good news and to invite them home. There are celebrations at that time in Bobby’s locality; perhaps someone was getting married ! and two Koli /fisherman songs cast in Goan music are played in sequence showing the vibrant culture , deep love between Raj and Bobby and a little lively repartee. As said above the two songs were penned byVithal bhai Patel. “ Na maangu sona chandi na mmangu bangla gaadi ye mere kis kaam ke ; deti hai dil de badle mein dil ke pyar mein sauda nahin” ( I do not ask for Bungalow or car, I do not ask gold or silver , if you want to give, then give your heart in return of my heart; there is no bargain in love ), the song appropriately suited the occasion and the proposal in hand which Raj brings with him . Immediately after the song is completed , Bobby flutters to the dance floor singing “ Jhoot bole kawwa kate kale kawe se dariyo main maike chali jaaungi tum dekhte rahiyo” ( if you tell a lie the black crow bites you , be afraid of him ; I shall go away to my parents and you keep watching! ). Now; this was a sort of reply to his boastful “ na maangu sona chandi…..”. In the song Dimple is draped in traditional 9 yard saree , which is worn by women in Maharashtra. She looks saucy and different. She dances so professionally . She; perhaps was trained so well that she has never danced like this thereafter on screen. This was celebration of love and there was expectation in the air. The couple was hopeful that in the meeting of their parents the matter would be resolved and they would marry soon. But , that was not to be . Jack Briganja ( Prem Nath ) Mrs Briganja his mother ( Durga Khote) and Bobby arrive in the palatial residence of Pran ( Raj’s father) . After the pleasantries Raj is asked to show Bobby around . The two parties are left to discuss the matter. Raj takes Bobby to his room and Raj presents her with a bottle in which a couple are dancing , they play with it; it depicts their happy state . But below there is problem ; Pran offers Jack money in return to keep Bobby away; Jack is insulted and furious ; they rise and leave. Jack shouts for Bobby who rushes with the gift in hand. Jack in his rage throws the bottle on the floor. It breaks ;Bobby sobs ; they leave ; but the image of the dancing couple does not break; they keep dancing. The audience in the hall understood the symbolism. Bobby is taken away from Bombay to Goa on board a ship. As the ship leaves harbor and Raj stands teary eyed on the shore the most soulful and heart stirring song of the film sung by Lata and penned byAnand Bakshi comes on screen in background –“ Ankhiyon ko rehne de ankhiyon ke aas paas , door se dil ki bujhti rahe pyas…..” ( let the eyes remain close to each other , from the distance our heart’s longing shall be satisfied) . Raj’s father plans his marriage to his friends daughter played by Farida Jalal , who is dim witted and plays her role well , there is grand party thrown on the occasion of engagement . Aruna Irani dances again on the occasion and sings the song “ uska luta ghar baar … dil main phansa”. Here again the words of the song reflect the situation in which Raj is engulfed. Raj runs away from home in his motor cycle, a mini ‘Bajaj bike’ which became very popular at that time . The Aruna Irani song being played in the background. On reaching he meets Bobby but his grandmother pulls away Bobby and locks her in a room . She is also successful in locking Raj in a room as she plans to inform his father of his whereabouts and to take him back home. However ; Raj manages to escape from the window of the bathroom and successfully releases Bobby from her captivity. The two ; run away to nowhere in Raj’s bike with the audience gleefully clapping abound. Whilst sitting on the bike and clutching Raj in tight embrace Bobby in a unique and novel expression of love bites the ear of her lover. Oh ! the audience not only approved the act but enjoyed along. This scene among others remained a talking point of the movie. When they run out of fuel they hitch hike on a truck and encounter the famous villain Prem Chopra who appears as Prem Chopra and incessantly slaps the two lovers and stating “ Main hun Prem ; Prem Chopra …”; this was again a new style and despite being of one scene it was remembered for long. The lovers escape his clutches and decide to drown in the river but are saved by their fathers who had been in the look out for them . The parents realize that they were wrong , and the young lovers were united for ever. 

 As I said that as in any good Indian film made for larger public the songs are not only central to the story but move the story and the story and the film is remembered through its songs.What made Bobby unique was also its casting. From main actors to the minor and character artists were cast correctly. Appropriate casting was one among the many qualities which Raj Kapoor possessed . Firstly; he had to present his son and work on his physique ; make him slim and trim from a chubby boy to a lover with him the young girls in the audience should fall in love! And he succeeded in that. Dimple was exotic ; from another world! If one was to describe her in one word , it would be ‘sophisticated’, ‘ class’. In addition she had that Regal beauty. No one had seen such a face before . As parents of Raj , Pran and Sonia Sahni were cast perfect; Pran was a known face and a versatile actor but Sonia was cast because she was beautiful and arrogant as required in character and was indeed a surprise pick. It is learnt that Raj Kapoor had asked Sadhna; the famous heroine for the role of Rishi’s mother but she declined; such was the insight and interest of Raj Kapoor in his films. For the parents of Bobby he cast Duga Khote as her Grandmother she had acted opposite Prithvi Raj Kapoor and was honoured with Dada Saheb Phalke award ; she played the caring and careful Christian Nanny to the T . For the role of Jack her father he cast his brother in Law ,Premnath – strong, robust , hardy , boisterous, who was in retirement after his successful stint as hero in sixties, as a swashbuckling star. His role as the main villain in Vijay Anand’s ‘Johny Mera Naam’ was so successful that he had an excellent return as a villain. Earlier he was seen in Raj Kapoor’s first successful film –Barsaat in 1949 in a parallel role opposite Nimmi and the memorable and eternal love song “ Barsaat main hum se mile tum, tum se mile hum Barsaat main”. In ‘Bobby’ his attire of Lungi , Koli topi and bandi was apt. when he goes to meet the parents of Raj , he has his own dignity , he carries his own Rum and wears an ill fitted suit like a good Christian going to Sunday Church. He has few scenes- the first is the introduction scene when he arrives on beach after his fishing sortie, the second was his introduction to Raj who has come home to ask Bobby out. The third is the famous scene when he is invited by Pran and pleads and weeps and in the end walks out to safeguard his self respect. The last is when he saves Raj from drowning. The villain in Prem Chopra his single dialogue made history. Aruna Irani in a flirtatious role , played her best role. Farida Jalal as a dim witted , doll like girl with wide eyes and dialogues suiting her mental state was again tapped correctly. All the above factors made the movie unique . 

 The film opened a new genre of subject and film making ‘ Teenage love story’, a subject not Taboo but never explored or experimented. Firstly ; the success of the theme and ‘teenage casting’ brought a large number of films on screen . In many Rishi was himself the hero – ‘Khel Khel Main’, ‘Rafuchakkar’, ‘Zinda Dil’, ‘ Jhoota kahinka’ and many more. But; Rishi remained a ‘young hero’ perhaps for a very long time. He was also cast with numerous new heroines in romantic roles- Nitu Singh ( he did maximum films with her and later married her too) was his most successful pair; Kajal Kiran ( Hum kisi se kum nahin), Shoma Anand ( Barood), Jaya Pradha in her first Hindi film ( Sargam ), Naseem ( Kabhi Kabhi ), Ashwani Bhave ( Henna) , Ranjeeta ( Laila Majnu ) and many more. Bobby gave rise not only to new love stories , but also to new romantic pairs one such successful and popular pair was that of ‘Sachin and Sarika’ s ‘Geet gaata chal’, was their most popular and successful film. Sachin also gave hit films with Ranjeeta ( Ankhiyon ke zaronkhon se ) and ‘Balika Badhu’ with Rajni Sharma. It also became a trend to try out a new ‘teenage couple’ for a film ; the motivation given by Bobby exists still. The film families were coming of age and their next generation was being prepared for the silver screen ; Raj Kapoor showed the way. Most of the actors/stars and actresses too launched their children based on the template prepared by Raj Kapoor/Bobby. Rajendra Kumar lauched his son Kumar Gaurav with Vijayte Pandit in ‘Love Story’ the film had good music by R D Burman and was successful . In the same year ( 1981) Sunil Dutt launched his son Sanjay Dutt opposite his girl friend Tina Munim in ‘Rocky’ which too was successful. Dharmendra lauched his son Sunny opposite new comer Amrita Singh in ‘Betaab’ written by Javed Akhtar and was a huge success, his second son was also launched with another star daughter Twinkle Khanna in ‘Barsaat’. Amir khan and Juhi Chawla were presented by Nasir Hussain in ‘Kayamat se Kayamat tak’ a hugely successful tragic love story, much later but here again ‘Bobby’ was the stimulus . Salman Khan and Bhagwashri another new couple was put on screen by Sooraj Barjatia in a block buster love story in 1989, ‘Maine Pyar Kiya’. Much later perhaps with Hritik Roshan the trend changed to love story plus action and so Macho new comers arrived. Recently son of Sunny Deol was launched in a romantic film ‘Palpal dil ke paas’. So the genre which Raj Kapoor created continues to inspire still; this was perhaps his greatest contribution. But; for us who had just entered our teens , it was a new world opened . The satisfying aspect was that the elders too liked the film and approved of it . But; for the society at large it was a door opened which was shut for long and it opened a shaft of sunlight for the generation to come . The sun shone brightly on the ‘teenage love story’ genre and its creator the Legend- Raj Kapoor. After Bobby, there was no sin in loving; there was no guilt; there was no wrong; there was no secret to love and seek love, to dream of love ;to search and woo our partner . even if our parents had led an unromantic/sedate life of conformism ; having been married in concurrence to the will of their parents . But this banner of love , this flag of romance every young wanted to hold and spree with it . Such was the strong undercurrent of this movie. Parents thought that this was seasonal and as it had come it would go. But; no Bobby changed things for ever. It had opened a lid, a horizon, a door to light and brightness, of freedom of chance to seek company ; to seek partner in life. 

 After more than 50 years of having seen the movie twice on its release , it is now that I ponder as to why the name of the film was ‘Bobby’ when it was a story of Raj and Bobby. But the writer Khwaja Ahmad Abbas and the producer –director Raj Kapoor did not make any change to the title . Yes; the film belonged to Bobby because she was the emancipator in the movie ;it is she who readily accepts the friendship of the rich boy on equal footing when she emerges with the background music playing like an ‘overture’ and says “ Main hun Bobby; mujhse Dosti karoge”. She agrees to go on a date with Raj after seeking her father’s approval. Now this was plausible in a Christian liberal home which Raj Kapoor selected as story. Therefore it is also a love story which is not a routine love story but a progressive story which imagines a new India which has broken its traditional mould and inter –religion marriage was acceptable. No where in the movie the question of her religion emerges . What emerges is class- conflict, the rich-poor question which continues to bog the Nation more still. Thank You Raj Kapoor! For liberating us.

 In dinon dil mera , mujhse keh raha 
 Tu khwaab saza,tu jile zaraa 
 Hai tujhe bhi ijazat kar le tubhi mohabbat 
 Hai tujhe bhi ijazat kar le tubhi mohabbat 

 Sayeed Kadri- Life in Metro (2007)

मंगलवार, 27 सितंबर 2022

Asha Parekh wins Dada Saheb Phalke award (does she desreve the same? )

 Asha Parekh wins Dada Saheb Phalke Award ( does she deserve it?)

Asha Parekh
Waheeda  Rehman



Vaijantimala




It was announced in today’s news that the veteran actress of Hindi cinema Asha Parekh won the prestigious ‘Dada Saheb Phalke Award’ which is given Annually to a person who has contributed to the image, growth and development of Cinema in India. It is not restricted to only Hindi Cinema but is Pan India  . Among its recipients have been Dilip Kumar, Raj Kapoor, Dev Anand, Devika Rani, Pran , Manna Dey and others .


Congratulations to Asha Parekh therefore for winning the same. She joined hindi cinema as a child artist but was cast as heroine in early sixties and then never looked back . She was considered as a lucky mascot and acted in films such as  Dil Deke dekho, Jab Pya Kisi Se Hota Hai, Teesri Manzil, Upkaar, Aaye Din Bahaar ke, Aaya Sawan Zhum ke,  Aaan Milo sajna, Shikaar, Mera Gaon Mera Desh , Main Tulsi Tere Aangan Ki, Love in Tokyo, Kati Patang.

    It is interesting to note that when the award was instituted 52 years ago in 1969 the first recipient was Devika Rani. Since then only Ruby Mayer ( Sulochna) , Durga Khote, Kanan Devi who were heroines have got it. It is understandable that being an All India award   it cannot be expected to be given to only heroines but to other disciplines too . Therefore both Lata Mangeshkar and asha Bhosle have got it . The prominent recipients from South have been Shivaji Ganesha, Rajni Kant, Adoor Gopalakrishna, K Vishvanath, L V Prasad and others. 


Only for some academic discussion it is worthy of mention that Nutan , Meena Kumari, Madhubala, Suraiyya, Hema Malini have not  not got the award. But; there are Two living  contemporaries of Asha Parekh who were much deserving than her , but have been overlooked- Waheeda Rehman and Vaijantimala.


 Asha Parekh was known to be a successful actress however she was never known for her acting skills . The lone filmfare award she received was for the film “kati-Patang’. An average actress but a lucky actress . And , yes she proved her luck once again by bagging the Phalke Award which gave a miss to Waheeda , vaijantimala but also to Dharmendra, Salim-Javed whose contribution was way ahead of Asha.


  Though Asha Parekh gave many successful films but none of her films other than ‘Teesri Manzil’ and ‘Mera Gaon Mera Des’ could be called great. Moreover both the above films were Hero centric. But Waheeda gave us Classics such as - Pyasa, Guide, Kagaz ke Phool, Chowdhvin ka Chand, Sahib bivi aur Gulam, Abhijaan ( Bengali with Satyajit Ray), Bees Saaal Baad , Reshma aur Shera, Muzhe Jine Do , Neel Kamal etc .  Waheeda won filmfare award for Guide and Neel Kamal and National award for ‘Reshma aur Shera’.


Vaijantimala  is known for her superhit and critically acclaimed films such as - Ganga Jamuna, Madhumati, Sangam , Jewel Thief, Amrapali, Devdas, Naya Daur. She has won four filmfare awards.


Therefore this award in my view was not fair . If anyone deserved it , it was Vaijantimala or Waheeda ; that is if it was to be given to a heroine . But the more deserving Dharmendra and , Salim and Javed were also there if it was to go to Hindi film industry.  







शनिवार, 4 जून 2022

NEHRU'S VIEWS ON ARYA SAMAJISTS 1936



 

Nehru’s Address to the Arya Samajists( 1936)




"It is up to the Arya Samajists to cooperate with the premier national

institution, but the Congress cannot bind itself to any conditions.

While bigger issues are shelved in the background petty problems

are being magnified to the detriment of the country’s progress.

I wonder how people in India can worry about sectarian problems

of civilization and culture when hunger and poverty are staring the

nation in the face.

 It is an imperative necessity to relieve all this which vitally affect

the country before people can apply themselves to any minor issues.

You should be straight and realistic and not waste time and energy

over extraneous matters.

In their welcome address the Arya Samajists had asked Jawaharlal as to what

safeguards the Congress would provide for protection of “Aryan civilization

and culture’’.

(Bareilly, 24 November 1936. From The Hindustan Times, 25 November, 1936,)

रविवार, 14 नवंबर 2021

Nehru’s Garhwal visit in May 1938

 

Nehru’s Garhwal visit in May 1938

 


 

Pandit Nehru visited Garhwal  in May 1938 , soon after the elections of 1937 which the congress won handsomely. He was the chief campaigner of the elections and people responded to his appeal with great love and admiration.

  He visited Garhwal for 5 days with his sister Vijaylakhsmi Pandit and Raja Huttising. His observations on his visit in 1938 may be more than 80 years old but some observations are relevant till date. What is interesting is that during his 5 day visit he grasped the social and economic condition and noted them and appealed for measures to be taken such as roads, hydroelectric projects, afforestation, schools, medical facilities, exploration of minerals etc. He feels very sad that not even ‘carriage roads

 

 were built( kachhi sadak).  What is disheartening is that even after so many years the situation has not improved despite the formation of a separate state of Uttarakhand. At that time too many people left villages for employment ,the barrenness of Garhwal hills continues. Perhaps the felling was more in Garhwal as the rivers were available for transportation , whereas the Kumaun hills remained unaffected as there are no major means of river transportation there .

   Nehru also observes that despite money spent on survey no railway or roads were built because the Government wanted to keep Garhwal in  political isolation as many soldiers were recruited from here.  One thing of importance emerges is that Nehru had regard for Garhwal people on account of the sacrifice of Veer Chandra Singh Garhwali , when he refused to fire on the people participating in civil disobedience movement; he was court martialed and sent to cellular jail.

 The poet and romantic in Nehru also emerges when he describes the rivers Alaknanda , Bhagirthi and Ganga . He writes “We were in the land of birth of the Ganga and this noble river, which we had known and loved so well in its rich and stately maturity, appeared before us now in its eager and joyful youth and its bubbling and gurgling childhood.”

  His comments on Srinagar in one letter to his sister Krishna are so true; he laments that such a beautiful place in Europe would have developed very fast. Alas! Even after attaining statehood we are far behind ! “We have been here since yesterday noon. Srinagar is situated in a broad and pleasant valley with the Alaknanda running through it. It is a small unpretentious little  town, though in olden times it was the capital of the Garhwali kingdom. Now it is cut off almost from the rest of the world by the lack  of even a carriage road. Such a site in Europe would be jumped upon and a beautiful town would grow up with villas all over the hill-sides and a brightly-lit city.”

And his lasting  impression of Garhwal is: “The abiding impression of Garhwal was one of isolation and poverty. It was extraordinary how near we were to the rest of the world and yet how cut off from it. Twenty miles represented now a hard day's journeying, as it must have been a thousand years ago or more. During these ages that had gone by there had hardly been any improvement in communications  and journeys were on foot or rarely on horseback. Only the telegraph wire spoke to us of science and the modem world .”

And ‘isolation and poverty’ may still be there ;women still carry their load on their head ; few have benefitted during these long years of Independence.

He is also forthright in his criticism of Garhwal people, when he says: “I must confess that I found a certain lack of enterprise among the people of Garhwal. They seemed to be resigned to their sad fate and their only reaction to it was to ask others to do something for them. They seldom thought in terms of doing something themselves. This was a natural outcome of long and distressing poverty and suppression and it will pass. For the Garhwalis are a brave and sturdy people and, given the chance, they will make good.

And he is reasonable too when he says that such an attitude could be the result of long years of distressing poverty and suppression; and that it shall pass.

Reproduced below is the full text of his written impressions of Garhwal and assessment and areas of improvement written in May 1938 and taken from his selected works vol 8:

 

 

A Visit to Garhwal-  by Jawaharlal Nehru-1938

My sister Vijayalakshmi and I have just spent five days in Garhwal . During these many years I have travelled a good deal in India and I have visited every district of the United Provinces, often more than once. But Garhwal remained unvisited except for a few hours given to Dugadda a year and a half ago. I was eager to fill this gap and, as always, the mountains attracted me. But the lack of communications necessitated a longer period and so I hesitated. But the insistence of friends in Garhwal and the consciousness of my own failure in the past induced me at last to repair this omission and to find a few days for these mountain valleys. I was happy to have as companions Vijayalakshmi and Raja Hutheesing as well as comrades from Garhwal. It was a delightful visit, though a strenuous one, and we have returned somewhat stiff of body but with our minds full of pleasant memories. We visited Gochar, Devaprayag, Srinagar and Pauri and many villages on the way. Our journeying was done by aeroplane, by car, on horseback and on foot, riding being the principal means adopted owing to the lack of cart roads. The aero-

 plane took us all the way to Badrinath and Kedamath and we had a near view of the snowy peaks which dominate these ancient places of pilgrimage. We could not land there and had to come back some way to Gochar where we landed. A great welcome awaited us there from the mountain folk and then we returned having completed by air within five hours a journey that takes as many weeks on foot,  From the air we saw Garhwal spread out below us with its bare mountains and its numerous valleys with rivers winding through them. We were in the land of birth of the Ganga and this noble river, which we had known and loved so well in its rich and stately maturity, appeared before us now in its eager and joyful youth and its bubbling and gurgling childhood. Having done with the air journey we took to the road and followed the Ganga from Risikesh to Devprayag, where the Bhagirti meets the Alaknanda and joining together drop their own particular names and become the ‘Ganga’, the river that has held India’s heart captive for  many thousands of years. Perched  up  precipices between the two rivers and across them,sits the  little town of  Devaprayag, looking down on the swiftly flowing currents  as they rush through rock-hewn gorges to meet and intermingle in warm embrace.

We reached Srinagar, situated in a broad and pleasant valley. The  Alaknanda flowed swiftly by it, carrying timber from its upper reaches. The town was a small one, fallen greatly from its old estate when it was the capital of the Garhwali kingdom. Here we stayed for two days and took part in the conference that was being held there and met many old comrades. We then proceeded to Pauri on the hill-top which gazes at the magnificent range of the northern snows. Badrinath and Kedarnath, the Chaukhamba and Trishul and even Nanda Devi.  All along the route we were met by the people from the villages, men and women and children, and warm-hearted affection came to greet us. A busy programme in Pauri and a night there, and then a| long and weary ride by a little frequented and badly kept route to Devaprayag, with halts and meetings on the way. From Devaprayag to Hardwar and back to railway train.

   The abiding impression of Garhwal was one of isolation and poverty. It was extraordinary how near we were to the rest of the world and yet how cut off from it. Twenty miles represented now a hard day's journeying, as it must have been a thousand years ago or more. During these ages that had gone by there had hardly been any improvement in communications  and journeys were on foot or rarely on horseback. Only the telegraph wire spoke to us of science and the modem world . The lack of cart roads throughout this wide-flung district is astonishing and for half a century there has been an insistent demand, ever growing louder, for a good road. We had heard of this before but we had not realized the passion behind it. Everywhere all sorts of people demanded and begged and shouted for a road. Everything else was secondary to them and Swaraj itself took the semblance of a road leading from the heart of the mountains to the plains below. They told us that it was a matter of life and death for them. 'Give us a road or we die' they pleaded.

   Why has this road-making been delayed so long in Garhwal?  It was expensive, cf course, but equally expensive roads have been made all over India in mountainous regions. During the  period of the World War the people of Garhwal were soothed by promises of a railway and a survey at a cost of many lakhs of rupees was actually made. But neither the railway nor a road materialized. If there had been a regiment stationed in Garhwal or any considerable British official presence, a road would have appeared soon enough. But officials do not look with favour on a sojourn in Garhwal and consider it as a kind of exile. Even inspection by high officials seldom takes place there. Still the road would have come

If there had not been some objection to it on the part of the British Government. I  imagine this objection was based on the  desire on the part of the government to keep Garhwal isolated and immune from political influences, as it was one of their chief recruiting areas. Garhwal regiments are well known, but I was surprised to learn that thousands of people from the district served in the armed police in Bengal. They are terribly poor and the land cannot sustain them in its present condition; they have hardly any industries, and so inevitably they seek employment elsewhere. We met large numbers of school children and I liked to ask them many questions. I found that over ninety per cent of them had never seen a railway train, or a motor car, or even a carriage. But they had seen an aeroplane flying over them; only some days before we had ourselves flown across.

Garhwal must have a road and that soon. It will never progress without it. But a road is not enough and what is urgently needed is to improve the productive capacity of the people. Apart from the question of the road the chief complaints were the lack of water, the heavy assessment, and the lack of medical help and schools. If a person fell seriously ill, it was not even .possible to carry him to some hospital nearby. He simply died or, if he was lucky, survived. The demand for education was great, even for girls, but the schools were few and far between.

The lack of water for the fields seemed strange, for there were several rivers with plenty of it and occasional springs. And yet .fields in the river valleys were lying dry and elsewhere they were worse off. We saw large numbers of terraced fields which had been cut out of the hill-sides with enormous labour, lying desolate and untended. They had been allowed to run waste as it was not considered worthwhile to cultivate them. Partly this problem of water has been aggravated by the lack of forests and the general  barrenness of the hill sides. Why Garhwal has such few forests while Kumaun abounds in them I do not know. The soil is as good and other conditions appear equally favourable.

Yet with all its poverty  and barrenness, Garhwal gave us an idea of great  potential strength and resources. There was water power running to waste everywhere when it could be converted into electricity and life-giving power for fields and industries. Probably there were plenty of minerals in the vast area only waiting to be developed.

let the road come to Garhwal, But equally urgent is an inquiry into its power resources and minerals. These power resources could supply electric power not only for Garhwal but to a large part of the province. Thus two expert inquiries seem called for immediately - one, for the utilization of water power and  the building up of hydroelectric schemes and the other into mineral of the area. While these schemes develop it may be possible to put up inexpensive pumps to send up the river water to the fields above. A scheme for afforestation should also be inquired into and begun.

Probably there are considerable opportunities for the development of cottage industries in Garhwal. Of these wool-spinning and weaving are the most obvious and they can be easily developed. An attempt to do so in Kumaun is meeting with success and there is every reason to believe that it will meet with equal success in Garhwal.  Bee-keeping is common in Garhwal but the methods adopted are primitive and wasteful. These could be easily improved. I must confess that I found a certain lack of enterprise among the people of Garhwal. They seemed to be resigned to their sad fate and their only reaction to it was to ask others to do something for them. They seldom thought in terms of doing something themselves. This was a natural outcome of long and distressing poverty and suppression and it will pass. For the Garhwalis are a brave and sturdy people and, given the chance, they will make good. They have become dear to  India for the gallant deed they performed eight years ago in the North West Frontier Province, when civil disobedience raged throughout India and the blood in our veins tingled as we took our part, big or small, in the struggle for freedom.

 

(Jawaharlal Nehru attended the District political conference in Srinagar Garhwal on 05 and 06 May 1938)

 

 

शनिवार, 13 नवंबर 2021

Nehru on 'staff work' and 'on foot to the polling booths'

 Nehru    on 'staffwork' and 'on foot to the polling booths'


We are aware that how much money is spent by all political parties during the elections. Numerous inducements are alleged to be offered to the voters to come to the polling booth and vote for the candidate of the party candidate. Expenditure in elections is a major issue and affects 'democracy'. But this was an issue even during the elections in 1937 ; before independence . Elections which congress won in most provinces. Jawaharlal Nehru was the main campaigner in the elections. Below is reproduced from the selected works of Nehru vol 8. Here he talks about 'staff work' by congress workers and also that the then congress did not believe in providing transport and food to voters in order to motivate them to come to the polling booths. Instead he advised  that people should march in groups carrying the flag  to the polling booths!!




On Foot to the Polls

 

Wherever I go, I find great enthusiasm for the cause of the Congress.

In the elections, enthusiasm and public meetings and demonstrations

are good, but more important for any big undertaking is staff work and

the careful working out of details. I find that little attention is paid

to this staff work by our committees. Mostly they concentrate on

demonstrations. This is not good enough and the first place should be

given to staff work. Some of the best workers in each province should

give up touring and sit at headquarters or visit places only for purposes

of inspections. Polling day arrangements especially must be fixed up

carefully. It must be clearly announced that the Congress cannot

make arrangements to carry voters by lorry or motor, nor do we provide

food as others do at the polling booths. The cry from us everywhere

must be, “On Foot to the Polling Booths". Let this be widely declared

and the rural voters should be encouraged to join parties marching

together from their villages with the national flag and singing national

songs and “On Foot to the Polls".

 

 

1. Statement to the press, Fyzabad, 15 January 1937. The Hindustan Times,

16 January 1937.

सोमवार, 8 नवंबर 2021

FIRAQ AS I KNEW HIM- BY R K GARG ( SENIOR ADVOCATE SUPREME COURT)

 

FIRAQ  AS I  KNEW HIM-    BY  R K  GARG ( SENIOR  ADVOCATE  SUPREME  COURT)

( CHAPTER  IN  A  BOOK-  ‘THUS  SPOKE  FIRAQ’-  A COLLECTION OF INTERVIEWS  BY  SUMANT  PRAKASH   SHAUQ-1992)

A  few  days before his death I had taken Firaq Sahib to the Medical Institute for admission. While my wife had gone to get the admission card ready , finding the waiting too tedious , sitting at the steering wheel  of the car with Firaq  in the back seat , I asked , “ Firaq Sahab , why after all are you against Gandhi  and what was your assessment of Jawaharlal?”  It was just a casual question to provoke  Firaq Sahib  break the unbearable tedium . I did not accept a serious answer . But Firaq took out a cigarette , took a little time to light the  match and drew a long puff, obviously trying to formulate  his answer rather precisely and with feeling. Then with effortless ease he replied  “ Gandhiji was a mountain of will . It was enough to frighten any human being . Therefore , Gandhiji  was not human in the ordinary sense  but had power to move millions into action  by his Herculean will . Nehru was different. If  you took an inch tape and measured the circumference  of the head of Jawaharlal alone , you will find the Head of Jawaharlal   bigger than the heads of all the world leaders together. That was Jawaharlal.”

     I could not take the answer  about Panditji seriously , I quite irreverently asked “ Firaq Sahib are you serious  about your assessment of Jawaharlal?”   He was provoked enough to justify why he had made this fantastic assessment of Nehru -  “ Don’t you know that in every moment of crisis , Jawaharlal’s response was always scientific   and Rational ? Could this be said of  any other leader?” This is true indeed. One’s thoughts  naturally went back to Churchill , Hitler, Mussollini, Stalin, Chaing Kai Shek, and even Rosevalt.  Firaq’s answer stands vindicated by History-  Nehru’s vision unfolded itself in the ‘Panchsheel ‘ and it is unfolding itself in the new thinking around the world  to restructure a new world order based  on universal  Human values and democracy . For Nehru, Democracy was a way of life . He believed   in resolving  the problems of life by discussion and dialogues with Scientific Temper.

रविवार, 15 मार्च 2020

REMEMBERING THOSE LOST EMOTIONS

REMEMBERING THOSE LOST EMOTIONS

Listening to the song of Asha Bhosle from 'Nau do Gyarah' –‘Dhalti Jaye  chundariya hamari ho Rama...Pi se milke bahakne ke din Aaye re.... I was recollecting our young days when the young had the heart to respond and appreciate such expression. All is lost now to modernity, technology, urbanisation, IT and to that Opiate Candy in our hand- The mobile.
We are a generation of regrets .
We have lost not only our emotions but romance , and yes indeed Love.
Our ability to understand and tolerate such songs has diminished. We offer lip service.
But first listen to these words. Here I write the full song:
“Dhalti Jaye chundariya hamari o Rama..Pi se milke bahakne ke din Aaye ho..
Jaise thandi Pawan banke pyar aa gayi
Jaise chupke se ban mein bahar aa gayi..
Pool banke
Ho phool banke mahakne ke din aye ho
Dhalti Jaye....

Mein to sapnon ki bagiya mein dolungi re..
Ban ki ban ke koyaliya mein bolungi re
Dali Dali
Ho Dali Dali chahakne ke din Aaye ho
Dhalki...”
Now the situation in the film is that Dev Anand and Kalpana Kartik are housed in a mysterious bungalow in hills and pretending to be Husband and Wife. Dev sleeps in the bathroom and she in bedroom but for the outside world they are a couple. Slowly love blooms.One day as Dev steps out in the morning K alpana offers him a cup of tea which he smilingly accepts. She then asks him to sit ,which he obliges. Silence. Dev finishes tea   ,and as he is about to walk out she say"Shall I walk with you to a distance”,he agrees. After sometime they are looking and smiling at each other and Dev say "Aaj chai Ka Maza aagaya( it was wonderful to have tea today)”.She blushes and covers her face with her hands . Dev smiles and pulls her sari pallu  down covering her face . And then he runs down...The song begins. This is the only solo song on Kalpana. The songs of this 1957film penned by Majrooh--- and composed by Sachin Dev Burman are gems, and this too is a gem, but sometimes a small gem gets overshadowed. This is what happened to this song.
Also with age the emotions evolve. I had seen this film in 1973 at 15year age in a morning show in Kanpur.
The core emotion of the song is:
I have lost balance after meeting my love, I have disregarded my appearance , lost I am in love.
“pi se milke bahakne ke din aye ho..”

The above means am intoxicated after meeting my love..my chundariya is falling ..and I am unaware.
Now such subtle expressions are neither heard nor understood. But those were the days when love was great and it was great to be in Love.
We regularly fell in love with our screen heroine. For days we were intoxicated. Till next Friday...